Scott Kinabalu 3 GTX review: High-tech comfort for hard trails

Now, in its third iteration, Scott’s Kinabalu 3 Gore-Tex shoe is billed as a complete redesign of the previous models. It features a raft of improvements in comfort, efficiency, and protection.

As a tech-forward shoe designed for comfort, efficiency, and protection, it excels on hard-packed trails. However, as made abundantly clear during my tests, its limitations on muddy terrain and lack of sustainability considerations might divide opinion.

Does the Scott’s Kinabalu 3 Gore-Tex belong in T3's best walking shoes for men guide? Who needs the shoes, and who should stay clear of them? Let's find out.

Scott Kinabalu 3 GTX review

Price and availability

The Kinabalu 3 Gore-Tex is widely available at Scott UK, Scott US, Scott AU, and third-party retailers. In the UK, prices typically range around £140-£150 from retailers like Cotswold Outdoor and Ellis Brigham. In the US, they’re listed for approximately $170 through Scott’s official site and select outdoor retailers. In Australia, expect to pay about AUD 280, with availability through Scott Sports and independent stockists. Prices vary by retailer and promotions, so it’s worth checking for discounts.

Design and materials

The Kinabalu 3 GTX features a ripstop mesh upper reinforced with thermoplastic polyurethane (TPU). This durable combination protects the upper while forming a lightweight rand and heel bumper, similar to technical walking boots.

Scott’s “Thermoplastic Polyurethane Support Cage” envelopes the foot, providing arch support through the tension of the laces. The flat laces, combined with a padded tongue, prevent pressure points, ensuring comfort.

The heel cup is generously cushioned and has some flex, adding to the shoe’s secure, supportive, and comfortable fit. However, the lack of recycled materials is a downside for eco-conscious buyers.

Performance and comfort

Scott’s Kinetic Foam midsole is the standout feature, offering impressive energy return – 14% more than traditional EVA, according to Scott. While specific figures are hard to verify, the midsole feels exceptionally plush. The 29.5mm stack height and 7mm drop strike a balance between cushioning and trail feedback, allowing users to maintain connection with the terrain.

The shoe’s “Evolved Rocker 2” technology enhances efficiency on the move, offering a smooth, natural stride. Despite minimal visible curvature in the sole, the rocker technology is noticeable during use. Flex is concentrated around the toe box, while the rear remains rigid, adding to stability.

The in-house sole unit, with its 3mm lugs, performs well on hard-packed trails but struggles on loose or muddy terrain. Although the widely spaced cleats shed mud effectively, the tread lacks the bite needed for more technical conditions.

Verdict

The Scott Kinabalu 3 GTX shoe offers a comfortable package for those looking to stick to hardpacked trails, as the tread pattern just isn't aggressive enough for much more. They are very comfortable, though, thanks to the tech-filled midsole and supportive upper.

Also consider

Hoka Speedgoat 5: Exceptional cushioning and grip, with Vibram Megagrip outsoles, suitable for technical trails and long-distance comfort.

La Sportiva Bushido II: A versatile option with aggressive traction and durable construction, great for technical terrain and challenging hikes.

Salomon X Ultra 360 Gore Tex: A more rugged alternative with better grip on loose and muddy terrain, designed specifically for hiking rather than trail running.