5 great Christmas movies with unthinkably low scores

Christmas classics with unfestively low ratings

Home Alone still
(Image credit: Twentieth Century Fox / Disney)

If you have some time out over the Christmas holiday break then it's the ideal time to watch some of the best festive movies – whether as a whole family or when the kids've gone to bed – from across the range of the best streaming services.

But sometimes something doesn't have to be actually good to be, y'know, good. That's why I've been scouring Rotten Tomatoes' Christmas movies list to find the five supposedly worst Christmas films streaming – with scores so low they seem to defy logic.

Each of the five selected has landed a 49% rating or less. I think the majority of entries here are particularly surprising – and there were plenty of others in close contention, too, from Miracle on 34th Street (1994) on 60%, to Home Alone (1990) at 66%, or Love Actually (2003) at 64%.

How the Grinch Stole Christmas



It may not be Dr Seuss's 1967 animated classic How The Grinch Stole Christmas, and it certainly couldn't be called a true classic in this turn-of-the-millennium format, but there's a lot to love about Jim Carrey's take on the Grinch in Ron Howard's movie adaptation.

Quirky is probably the kindest way to put it, but the kids will love the Grinch's peculiar green face and frankly odd antics, while adults will smirk at the sheer madness of the whole series of events. It's a fun movie – and many consider it a classic.

Despite some darker undertones, there's still a warm heart at the centre of this Grinch adaptation – and that's what makes a Christmas movie Christmasy – which ensures it's a family-friendly affair. But a mere 49% score? C'mon!

Home Alone 2: Lost in New York

Home Alone 2: Lost in New York (1992) Trailer #1 | Movieclips Classic Trailers - YouTube Home Alone 2: Lost in New York (1992) Trailer #1 | Movieclips Classic Trailers - YouTube
Watch On


I shed a little tear to learn that the Home Alone sequel, Lost in New York, which was released in 1992, scored a mere 35% on Rotten Tomatoes from critics.

The original and this sequel are, in my opinion, utter Christmas classics. Sure, we can ignore any version thereafter – but the first pair are cult classics. It's a feel-good movie that reflects the cheer of the festive period – especially in this movie's snowy New York setting.

Sure, any sequel to Macaulay Culkin's classic first outing was going to be hard to follow. And when you watch it back, the degree of violence inflicted upon bad guys Harry and Marv wouldn't pass the sensors with a PG rating these days, but that marks it out all the more as a movie of its time. The 90s, eh? What a time to be alive.

Jingle All The Way

Jingle All the Way (1996) Trailer #1 | Movieclips Classic Trailers - YouTube Jingle All the Way (1996) Trailer #1 | Movieclips Classic Trailers - YouTube
Watch On


I'm not purporting that Arnie's performance in Jingle All The Way is in any way quality, but it's often hilarious – and every time this movie comes on TV I feel inclined to Watch It All The Way through. That's despite it landing a pretty terrible 20% score on Rotten Tomatoes from critics, with viewers not far behind – at 43% approved.

Once this might have been the closest thing we'd get to a Christmas superhero movie – a gap clearly spotted by 2024's Red One, which is dominating charts. Still, Jingle's out-and-out awfulness won't be grasped by the kiddos, yet your eyes will remain glued to the screen for the sheer hilarity of it all. It's worth it just to hear Arnie utter 'Turbo Man' umpteen times, really...

Jack Frost

Jack Frost (1998) Official Trailer - Michael Keaton Family Snowman Drama Movie HD - YouTube Jack Frost (1998) Official Trailer - Michael Keaton Family Snowman Drama Movie HD - YouTube
Watch On


This is one of Michael Keaton's worst-rated movies ever – at least according to Rotten Tomatoes, where it lands just 19% – and you don't want to confuse this Jack Frost with the unrelated Christmas horror movie that came before it in 1997. Although I can see how you might, as this is not exactly a cheery nor light-spirited film.

But despite those points, I feel Jack Frost is a seasonal route into addressing issues about family, about loss, about the idealism of success, and ultimately about growing up in the modern world. If you're having one of 'those days' then don't rule it out, its 40% audience score shows there's still a little bit of festive love for it...

Deck The Halls

Deck the Halls (2006) Official Trailer #1 - Danny DeVito Movie HD - YouTube Deck the Halls (2006) Official Trailer #1 - Danny DeVito Movie HD - YouTube
Watch On


Well, we have a winner! I watched Deck the Halls over Christmas last year and, yes, it is indeed a terrible movie. But as a feel-good and entirely silly Christmas flick it's a great and easy watch. That Danny DeVito also stars gives it added appeal, as he's such a classic star.

The premise is about neighbours who ultimately get into 'Christmas lights wars', trying to take their homes to the next level (like view-it-from-space levels). If you live in an area like mine then I'm sure you'll be able to entirely relate to that.

As bad as Deck the Halls gets there's always some compelling reason to remain watching – even if just to see whether you agree with its unbeatably low 6% Rotten Tomatoes score!

Mike Lowe
Tech Editor

Mike is T3's Tech Editor. He's been writing about consumer technology for 15 years and his beat covers phones – of which he's seen hundreds of handsets over the years – laptops, gaming, TV & audio, and more. There's little consumer tech he's not had a hand at trying, and with extensive commissioning and editing experience, he knows the industry inside out. As the former Reviews Editor at Pocket-lint for 10 years where he furthered his knowledge and expertise, whilst writing about literally thousands of products, he's also provided work for publications such as Wired, The Guardian, Metro, and more.